Crimson Captain is a matching outfit offered for purchase by the Peddlers on Padres Del Fuego, Cuba, Port Royal, and Tortuga. It has a red theme and a hat similar to the Black Buccaneer Hat and the Scoundrel Hat.
- Complete Outfit (female): 8,550 Gold
- Complete Outfit (male): 8,050 Gold
- In-Stock Dates (POTCO): June 2011, August 2012, September 13th 2013
- In-Stock Dates (TLOPO): None